Contents: Some thoughts about propolis in the hive
- John Yates, Therry Apiculture Northern France - Robin & Jenny Spon-Smith,
Matt Allens View EMERSON - AN IDIOT,Theday that changed
my life - Peter Springall, Moir Rare Book Collection consists of 233 volumes
relating to bees and beekeeping, John Brown, John Pearce, Beekeeper awarded
the MBE Michael Badger. Please wait while downloading 291KB
Photograph of Michael giving
a prize to Jan Davis at the AGM of an Avon BKA branch meeting
EDITORIAL Welcome to the first edition of Apis
UK for the New Year from a very cold Andalucia.
As promised we deal firstly with the GMO survey which despite
many comments to the contrary, I think was an interesting exercise
in bringing together peoples' thoughts. So what did you have to
say? Unfortunately several readers did not want their letters
to be published and so I was left with 4, one of which I lost.
However, 4 are better than none. So here we go, just 2 days later
I read a report that claims that farmers growing certain GM crops
may actually be benefiting insects and the environment! (See below).
THE GMO SURVEY
Meaningless! Polarising the issue! Wrong questions asked! A disservice!
Confused! Achieves nothing! Just some of the comments received
referring to the GMO survey. You can see some of the letters in
the letters to the editor section of the newsletter. All interesting
and all expressing as many different viewpoints as there are writers.
(And to the gentleman who wrote that I am polarising the issue,
I must humbly apologise. I have lost the letter by clicking the
wrong bit of the screen). But we can start with that one. Another
writer in a letter not for publication wrote that I hadn't polarised
it sufficiently and with this I tend to agree. The wrong questions?
Probably. Ask 100 people and you will get 100 questions that you
should have asked. A meaningless survey? Possibly in terms of
numbers it is not an important survey, but it is not a scientific
exercise, and all surveys have meaning if only to show and remind
those who try and avoid the issue that there is a big issue that
needs to be addressed. Surveys also stir readers into thinking
about what they think of the issue even if all they do is write
in and slam the survey. They share their thoughts with others.
This adds to the knowledge of others and stirs readers to think
even more. With one reader I had a series of exchanges on the
matter by email. I learnt a lot and I hope he did too. I believe
that it makes many readers realise that they don't know enough
about the subject to answer. If following that, even just one
person decides to do something about it, then that is all to the
good. As for being confused; who isn't? I could go on, but will
close on what I believe has been an interesting survey and to
genuinely thank those who participated, especially those who wrote
in. Interpreting the results I leave to you. I was surprised by
them, and I believe others will be too. It certainly isn't a black
and white issue.
That magnificent American writer, scientist, teacher and conservationist
Rachel Carson wrote in 1962 (Silent Spring):
"The 'control of nature' is a phrase conceived in arrogance,
born of the Neanderthal age of biology and philosophy when it
was supposed that nature exists for the convenience of man.....
It is our alarming misfortune that so primitive a science has
armed itself with the most modern and terrible weapons and that
in turning them against the insects it have also turned them against
the earth".
She was writing about insecticides and herbicides, but could equally
be writing about the science of genetic modification and were
she alive now, I believe she would. I personally think that she
sums it up nicely.
If GMO research
was stopped completely, do you think: (94 votes)
A. We would be abandoning a young
science that if perfected may bring enormous benefits to mankind
and the planet
36 Votes
B. We would be saving mankind and
the planet from potential or actual disaster
31 Votes
C. You don’t know enough about the
subject.
27 Votes
OTHER MATTERS
On to other matters. The decision of the trustees of the Moir
collection of books to lend them to the National Library of Scotland
(See in the news below) is very welcome. Let's hope that many
more people are able to access such a fund of apicultural literature.
And an MBE for services to Beekeeping (See below).
How marvellous. Many congratulations to Michael Badger MBE. (For
those readers from overseas, the MBE is an honour bestowed by
HM the Queen upon very well deserving citizens for excellent services
rendered in their particular field).
And finally, another new site (well
it will be new in February). www.interhoney.com.
(See news below). I'm always impressed with entrepreneurial spirits
trying new ventures and I really hope that this one succeeds.
I doubt that beekeepers would need to use its services, but who
knows?
A happy New Year to you all and I hope that you enjoy this month's
Newsletter. Keep in touch. If you have something to say on any
aspect of apiculture, share it with us.
David Cramp. Editor.
NEWS INTERHONEY.COM
A new site to rival Interflora commences operations
in February. The aim of these brave entrepreneurs is to provide
a personalised gift honey delivery service to any part of the world
within 48 hours. See their site at http://www.interhoney.com
GM CROPS 'WILL HELP WILDLIFE'
Farmers who plant some genetically modified (GM) crops could help
endangered species to thrive, UK scientists believe. They say their
work is the first to show there can be environmental benefits from
GM strains. They argue that crops can be managed to produce ample
weeds and insects for wildlife, without sacrificing yields. The
full story can be found at the BBC News Online website: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/2658401.stm
The Apimondia Apitherapy Commission would like
to report on the symposium it organised in Havana, Cuba on 14-18
October 2002. The symposium was sponsored
by the Ministry of Health and the Callixto Garcia Faculty of Medicine
and was held in that faculty's teaching hospital. The Commission
would particularly like to thank Cubana de Aviacion, which has always
supported it and allowed foreign participants to benefit from a
preferential rate.
More than 180 people from 14 different countries
took part in the symposium. Of these individuals, 2/3 followed Level
1 and the apitherapy practitioners participated at Level 2. The
Apitherapy Commission sent six professors who worked for the first
time alongside five Cuban professors to pass on knowledge of apitherapy.
Some 53 health institutions from all over the island were represented.
During the opening ceremony, Dr Leoncio Padron, the national representative
for natural medicine speaking for the Minister of Health, reaffirmed
the national dimension of apitherapy, congratulated the teams on
the results achieved and prompted new students to cultivate a passion
for this health solution. The Dean of the Faculty, Dr Eva Miralles
Cáceres, and the Director-General of the Hospital, Dr. Armando
Guerra Vilanova, also welcomed those participating in the symposium
while delighting in the leading position occupied by the university
and the Callixto Garcia Hospital from year to year. In his inaugural
speech, the Director-General informed the assembly of the important
role played by apitherapy in his hospital. All of the 34 departments
making up the hospital make some use or other of the therapy. This
information confirmed to all the participants not only the potential
of this knowledge, but also the specific successes enjoyed in the
past six years.
Professor Théodore Cherbuliez spoke of the
2,600 cases treated under this method, the recognition of the pharmacopoeia
of bee products as a source of medication and the sharing of these
results with the other countries present. "Cuba has been able
to open its doors and offer its skills to allow others across the
world access to this revolution in the field of health. The Commission
can be justifiably proud of this step, which will principally allow
the countries of the South to benefit from the skills acquired",
stated the President of the Apitherapy Commission in his inaugural
speech.
The symposium was held over 5 days, offering 40
hours of courses. At each level, both theoretical and clinical aspects
were touched on. The students, who studied biology, pharmacy and
medicine, were able to learn in depth about this natural medicine.
The friendly atmosphere of this international gathering led to many
very interesting discussions.
Before the closing ceremony, each participant was
issued an attendance certificate. A question-and-answer session
allowed all the unvoiced questions to be asked, especially those
on the subject of the next course. Our President, Professor Théodore
Cherbuliez, reaffirmed that the Apitherapy Commission was always
available to the Minister of Health to continue and widen the teaching
of apitherapy, not only via symposia but also via ongoing training,
as has been the case for the past six years in Cuba. He emphasised
that many other countries were waiting for this health solution,
but that for the Commission, Cuba would remain the first country
in both heart and deed. The symposium closed on that humanitarian
note.
Here is a piece of non bee news that will undoubtedly
be of interest to beekeepers and all interested in bees (From Nature).
INSECTS AND EVOLUTION
The science journal 'Nature' reports that scientists have shown
that some insects lost and then regained their ability to fly.
Researchers had thought that it was impossible for an organism to
re-evolve a complex trait such as wings and flying, but now it appears
that certain stick insects have proven them wrong.
After examining DNA from 35 species of stick insects, evolutionary
biologist Michael Whiting and other researchers at the Brigham Young
University in Utah found that wings had been lost in some of the
primitive insects and then re-evolved at least four times over tens
of millions of years.
"Traditional thought for the last two centuries has been that
wings had only evolved once in evolution but our study demonstrates
that in stick insects wings were re-evolved on multiple occasions,"
Whiting said.
This research challenges challenges basic beliefs of evolution that
wings evolved only once in insects and that if a trait is lost is
cannot be regained.
It also opens a new direction for research because it shows that
once a complex trait has evolved it can be maintained over long
evolutionary period even if it isn't apparent on the outside.
Over a 50-million year period, even though the stick insects did
not have wings the genes for creating them appeared to have been
maintained. Thus the insects had the ability to generate wings when
they needed them," Whiting explained.
He likened his observation to a mammalogist discovering a whale
walking around on legs.
"It really is quite a remarkable and revolutionary idea,"
he added. Scientists had believed that once a trait was lost it
was gone forever because the genes needed to create it would be
changed, but Whiting said the genetic instructions to produce wings
and legs are probably related and can probably be switched on and
off over millions of years to enable the insects to better adapt
to their environment. He suspects re-evolution may have occurred
in other species including cockroaches and different insects and
possibly other animals. (I wonder if that is why we humans often
dream of flying. Perhaps we once did! Ed).
John Brown
I've been asked by my family to get in touch with the beekeeping
community online and pass on the bad news that my uncle, John Brown,
passed away on new year's day. He wrote the brief on Varroa entitled
"Varroa Can Be Overcome" that is available at http://www.beedata.com/data2/green_husks.htm
I understand that a lot of people have been very
grateful to him for his insight on this subject. My uncle never
had access to the Internet himself and had asked a friend to post
this information online to help others with this problem. Yours
sincerely, Steven Palmer grondle@aol.com
John Brown
1922 - 2003
(We were very sad to hear of the passing of your
uncle J T Brown. He was one of the first supporters of Beedata when
we appealed for beekeeping information to add to the Beedata website.
I have seen a number of articles published referring to the Internet
link. Your uncle must have recognised that the Internet was the future
way to disseminate information to beekeepers around the world. Ed).
Jonn Pearce It's sad news to report the passing of a well known Kent beekeeper
and Bromley branch member John Pearce. John was an excellent beekeeper
and a superb showman at national and local show and will be missed
tremendously by his beekeeping friends. We at Bromley branch send
our condolences to his wife and family. Steven Turner
Photograph showing John (left) receiving an
award
New Years Honours List - Beekeeper awarded the MBE Michael Badger from Roundhay, Leeds has been awarded the MBE
in the New Years Honours List for Services to the British Beekeeping
Industry. This award will be seen as a great boost to beekeeping and
well deserved by Michael.
Michael has been actively involved with beekeeping
since a childhood. He has been involved in all spheres of beekeeping
he has been the National President of the British Beekeepers' Association
and its Chairman. In addition, the Chairman (twice) of the Yorkshire
Beekeepers' Association and its General Secretary and is The Yorkshire
Agricultural Society's representative to the Yorkshire Beekeepers'
Association. He has been the Chief Honey Steward at the Gt. Yorkshire
Show for over twenty years and a Senior Honey Judge for many years,
participating at all the top agricultural shows in the British Isles.
Mr Badger is the Secretary General of the National
Council of Beekeeping Associations in the United Kingdom a role
that involves regular attendance at the COPA-COGECA meetings for
the EU Honey Working Party at Brussels. He gives lectures worldwide,
in April he will be meeting beekeepers in San Francisco and Los
Angeles with visits to others in the third world during 2004.
Out of beekeeping Michael is a Director of an Environmental
Management Consultancy and a publishing house. He his married to
Hilary and they have three children.
Erica Osborn
DANGER FROM YET MORE BUGS
Tropilaelaps clareae and Aethina tumida
In an article in the latest edition of the IBRA journal Bee World,
3 experts from the UK National Bee Unit (Central Science Laboratory)
review the biology of the parasitic honey bee mite Tropilaelaps clareae
and the small hive beetle Aethina tumida and assess the risk of them
becoming established in the UK. (The small hive beetle was reviewed
in the November issue of Apis UK).
Both pests are serious threats to beekeeping and their spread around
the world is of great concern.
T. clareae is a parasitic brood mite whose principle host is the giant
Asian honey bee. Apis dorsata, but is known to be associated with
A. mellifera. Like Varroa destructor, T. clareae has been described
as being in an interphase state in A.mellifera colonies in that the
parasite can live and reproduce on the new host, but will cause it
to die. Colony collapse is reported within 1 year. It's exact geographical
limits are not precisely known and its lifecycle and parasitism of
A.mellifera is similar to that of varroa. The article describes the
full life cycle of the mite and states that when infesting the same
colony as varroa, it builds up faster than and out competes varroa.
It is a well established pest of A. mellifera in Asia, damaging colonies
within a few months and causing colony collapse within a year. So
can it come to the UK? That it could escape from tropical Asia and
become established in the USA has been evaluated and a conclusion
based on circumstantial evidence was that both were possible. Factors
that can affect the survival of the mite during transport, including
time taken, availability of brood during winter periods, temperature
etc are discussed and the authors conclude that in certain parts of
the UK where climate permits eg SW England and W. wales, where brood
may be present all winter the mite may then conceivably cause serious
damage to colonies. (The mite can survive for 5-7 days without brood
according to some research, but there are large data gaps in respect
of survivability in low temperatures and in brood less periods). Where
temperatures dictate a complete interruption of brood, the mite is
considered unlikely to survive, but worryingly, colonies from Dorset,
Suffolk, Notts, Cumbria and N. Yorks, where brood levels in the autumn
and winter were profiled, it was noted that there is brood in at least
some of the colonies during the winter, with broodless periods occurring
at different periods in the colonies, with one colony in York rearing
brood continuously until February. As long as bees rear some brood,
the mite can survive. The authors do re iterate however that there
is limited knowledge on its ability to survive in UK conditions.
The mite could be introduced through attendant or packaged bees possibly
after having become established in Southern Europe, but if the worst
did come to the worst, all is not totally lost because the authors
also state that control is considered relatively straightforward by
using husbandry methods that simulate brood less periods or through
certain chemical treatments.
On the small hive beetle front, the authors state that temperature
requirements are readily met in the UK, and the requirement for sandy
soils would also be met in many areas and so if imported, would become
a serious pest to both honey bees and it is suggested to bumble bees.
The full article by Mike Brown, Helen Thompson and Medwin Bew can
be read in Bee World, Vol. 83 (4) 2002. See www.ibra.org.uk.
(I personally think that all beekeepers should read up on this
subject and then if it does happen, we will be more prepared than
we where with varroa. In the meantime be careful with your imports.
Ed).
A NEW BOOK FROM AN ACKNOWLEDGED EXPERT When Leslie Goodman* finally lost her fight against lung cancer
in 1998, (see obituary in Bee World 79(2) 1998), she left behind
her vision for an accessible, authoritative reference work for bee
scientists, undergraduates, and beekeepers.
Her aim was to describe some of the topics in bee
biology which would target a broad audience. She left the partially
completed manuscript of the book to the trustees of the L.J Goodman
Insect Physiology Research Trust with a request that the book be
completed and published by the International Bee Research Association
(IBRA). The Chair of the Trust, Richard Cooter* together with Pamela
Munn of IBRA had the responsibility to complete the book on her
behalf. They are both now proud to announce that the finished book
entitled 'Form and Function in the Honeybee' is to be published
this month. The book contains over 340 diagrams, micrographs and
colour illustrations that are carefully integrated in the text,
this book serves equally well as an expert guide to the physiology
and anatomy of the honey bee and as an introduction to this fascinating
field for students and others. The chapters take the reader through
the major structures and activities of the honey bee providing a
comprehensive understanding of how and why it behaves as it does.
The book is available from IBRA at a pre publication
price of £45 (prior to 31 Jan so get there quickly) or £55
thereafter. P&P is £5, 8 Europe, £15.50 elsewhere.
More details can be obtained from www.ibra.org.uk.
*Dr Leslie Goodman became lecturer in the department of Zoology
and comparative physiology at Queen Mary College London. She later
became a Senior Lecturer and then in 1977 a Reader in Zoology in
the School of Biological Sciences. Her research interests were chiefly
in the field of neurobiology and insect physiology in particular,
visual physiology. She started her book 'Form and Function in the
Honey bee' which was almost completed by her death in 1998.
*Richard Cooter was formerly Professor of Applied
Entomology and Head of the Agricultural Resources Management Department,
Natural Resources Institute, University of Greenwich.
A SWARM OF BOOKS IS WELCOMED INTO A NEW HIVE The Scottish Beekeepers' Association
deposited its rare book collection in the National Library for a period
of 50 years. Dr Brian Hillyard, Head of Rare Books, describes the
collection and its background:
The Moir Rare Book Collection consists of
233 volumes relating to bees and beekeeping. We've all grown up
with bees as part of our cultural heritage as well as with honey
on the breakfast- or tea-table. In the ancient world honey was important
as a sweetener, and early on people saw a resemblance between the
production of honey by bees and literary composition, especially
in poetry. Another thread in literature and thought has been the
well-governed community of the hive and the communal altruism of
bees, as described by. The point is that bees are not merely creatures
encountered in a zoological textbook, but mean a lot more to us.
The Moir Library, of which this is part, is a collection
of books that was formed in Scotland by John William Moir,
and we were very pleased to welcome his grandson, Archimandrite
John Maitland Moir, the Orthodox Chaplain to the University of Edinburgh,
to the Library.
Born in Edinburgh in 1851, John Moir, with his younger
brother Frederick, inspired by the example of David Livingstone,
emigrated in 1877 to southeast Africa where they were initially
involved in the creation of new routes enabling ivory to be transported
without slave-gangs. Later, he turned to farming in present-day
Malawi, and took up beekeeping because his crops required pollenation.
Returning to Scotland in 1890, he settled in Edinburgh and beekeeping
became his hobby. In 1912 he became one of the original members
and the first vice-chairman of the Scottish Beekeepers' Association,
and he then started to collect bee literature in a serious way.
The more books he acquired, the more he actively searched for those
he lacked. And some of his surviving papers show that he drove a
hard bargain. One of our exhibits is a copy of the 1634 edition
of Charles Butler's Feminine Monarchie that he acquired in 1920
from the famous London booksellers Bernard Quaritch. The receipt
accompanying it shows that he had been charged the full price of
£2/0/0d., but pleaded for a discount on the grounds that the
Scottish Beekeepers' Association had bought books from Quaritch
before and that its funds were 'almost exhausted'. I'm sure that
Quaritch often received letters like this, but Moir got his discount.
In 1916, when his collection numbered 167 volumes,
Moir willed it to the Scottish Beekeepers' Association, but later
he changed his plans to give his fellow members the benefit of the
collection during his lifetime. To this end, he presented them to
the Association on the understanding that he would remain Honorary
Librarian and house the collection at his home. He died in 1940,
but the previous October his library, which by then numbered 1,799
books and pamphlets and 489 volumes of periodicals, had been transferred
into the custody of the Edinburgh Public Libraries, where, except
for the Rare Book Collection, the remainder continues to be housed,
at present in Fountainbridge Branch Library.
So, a collection carefully assembled in Scotland
by an enterprising Scot. Most of the books deposited date from before
1801. There are also some Scottish books in it - some very rare
Scottish books. Consider for example the book by Robert Russell
of Elgin. At the age of 15, this man - or boy - wrote a treatise
on bees and beekeeping and designed and cast his own typeface, set
the type, and then built his own press in order to print his work.
He was known to have made only two copies of his first edition,
dated 1822, and of these only one has been traced, in Cornell University
in the United States. How Moir would have loved to have acquired
a copy of this, but, alas, he never did! But some years later, in
1834, Russell brought out a 'much enlarged, corrected, and improved'
second edition, and this - one of only three known copies - is in
the Moir Collection.
The Moir Collection is an international collection
too with foreign-language books reaching back to 1525 (an edition
of Pliny's Natural History). Among the items from mainland Europe
pride of place must go to a 1625 engraving. The compound microscope
was invented at the end of the 16th century, and in 1618 Francesco
Stelluti and other members of the Accademia dei Lincei, Rome, which
had been founded in 1603 and of which Galileo was a member, used
a microscope to produce enlarged drawings of bees: these were the
earliest drawings of insects prepared with the help of a microscope,
and the 1625 engraving by Matthaeus Greuter from the Accademia's
drawing is the earliest engraving from a drawing prepared with the
help of a microscope. Only four copies of this engraving are known;
the other three are in Rome, Florence, and Pisa. Another rare item
within the Moir Collection is a 1630 edition of an Italian translation
of the Satires of the Roman poet Persius, published by Francesco
Stelluti and incorporating a re-engraving of this drawing - the
first illustration prepared with a microscope to be included in
a printed book. This image was adapted by the Scottish Beekeepers'
Association for its bookplate.
This outstanding collection - one of the finest
of bee literature in the world - is on deposit to secure improved
public access both now and in the future. The Scottish Beekeepers'
Association has always permitted access to its early books, but
we hope to promote this rare material and make it available to visitors,
answer enquiries about it from remote users, and provide an in-house
reprographic and digitisation service - all with the proper safeguards
so that access to these resources can be provided for future generations
as well as our own.
For further information on this release please contact:
Fiona Morrison/Alison Rae
National Library of Scotland
tel 0131 622 4807
email f.morrison@nls.uk
MORE BEEKEEPING COURSES 2003 UK ORGANISATION: Northamptonshire BKA TITLE: Beginners Course SUBJECT: Getting started in beekeeping. Eight weeks of lectures
with two practical sessions handling bees. VENUE: Abbey Centre, Hunsbury, Northampton DATE: Start 1 February 2003 TIME: Saturday mornings 9.30 am - 11.30 am FEE: £30.00 per person CONTACT: Margaret Holland Tel: 01327 857328 E-mail: secretary@northantsbees.org.uk
WEB SITE: www.northantsbees.org.uk
ORGANISATION: Northamptonshire BKA TITLE: Beekeeping Taster Day SUBJECT: Open a hive and experience bees close-up. Sample
honey and see how mead, beeswax candles, beeswax polish, hand creams
and other products derived from the hive are easily made. VENUE: Knuston Hall, Knuston, Nr. Irchester, Wellingborough DATE: 17 May 2003 TIME: 9.00 am - 5.00 pm FEE: £25.00 per person, to include coffee, lunch, afternoon
tea. CONTACT: Margaret Holland Tel: 01327 857328 E-mail: secretary@northantsbees.org.uk
WEB SITE: www.northantsbees.org.uk
ORGANISATION: Northamptonshire BKA TITLE: One Day Refresher Course SUBJECT: Revision of the basics of beekeeping for those new
to beekeeping with an opportunity to take the BBKA Basic Exam (optional). VENUE: Knuston Hall, Knuston, Nr Irchester, Wellingborough TIME: 9.00 am - 5.00 pm DATE: 28 June 2003 FEE: £26.00 per person, to include coffee, lunch, afternoon
tea. CONTACT: Margaret Holland Tel: 01327 857328 E-mail: secretary@northantsbees.org.uk
WEB SITE: www.northantsbees.org.uk
ORGANISATION:Ipswich & E Suffolk BKA TITLE: Beekeeping for Beginners DATE: 24th March 2003 CONTACT: Jeremy Quinlan jquinlan@freebie.net
DATES FOR YOUR DIARY Event organisers are welcome to forward
dates and details of their events to the editor (by e-mail) for
incorporation on this page.
Saturday 22 February 2003 - SBKA 2003 LECTURE
DAY. The Somerset Beekeepers' Association will be holding their
Lecture Day on (Those who already have their 2003 diaries, please
note this is a different date to the one announced at the 2002 Lecture
Day) We are putting together, what we think, is an interesting programme
of lectures. Finalisation of the programme has been delayed as one
of the lecturers had to withdraw, but the programme should be available
early in October. The lecturers are Dr Ruth Waite (nee Spinks),
Dr Michael Keith-Lucas, Robin Dartington, Margaret Thomas NDB and
Richard Ball, RBI. The cost for the Lecture Day for non-SBKA members
is £12 and this includes a ploughman's lunch with dessert
and refreshments during the day. The venue is the St. Ivel Lecture
Hall at the Bath and West Showground near Shepton Mallet. If any
of your members would like to attend, tickets will be available
from the SBKA Education Officer, Mrs Caroline Butter, The Old Manse,
Draycott, Cheddar BS27 3SF from 8 January 2003. Prior to that date
tickets will only be available to our SBKA members. From 8 January
2003 tickets will be available on a "first come, first served"
basis as we are limited to 100 seated in the lecture hall. If you
require any more information, please do let me know. Mrs Sharon
Blake e-mail: m-s.blake@overstratton.fsnet.co.uk PROGRAMME updated 3/12/02
9am - Coffee
9.30am - Opening by The President
9.35am - Have All Your Colonies Survived the Winter? - Margaret
Thomas NDB
10.40am - On the Honey Trail - Dr Michael Keith-Lucas
11.45am - Coffee
12 noon - Bugs, Bees and Disease: Research in to Bee Diseases at
the NBU - Dr Ruth Waite
1.05pm - 1st Lunch followed by Pyrethroid Resistance and EFB: Implications
for Bee Husbandry - Richard Ball at 1.50pm
1.05pm - Pyrethroid Resistance and EFB: Implications for Bee Husbandry
- Richard Ball followed by 2nd Lunch at 1.50pm
2.35pm - How Satisfied Are You With Your Beekeeping? - Robin Dartington
3.40pm - Tea
3.55pm - Your First Visit to the Bees - Margaret Thomas NDB
5.pm - Close
1st March 2003- Bucks County Beekeepers AssociationANNUAL SEMINAR To be held on March 1st 2003 at Wendover Memorial
Hall from 10am to 4.0pm. Speakers:- Glynn Davies - Chairman BBKA
'The bees knees' Celia Davis -Gardening for Bees Andy Johnston -"Never
trust an expert" (thoughts on Queen rearing) Cost:- £10
for BBKA members, £11 for non-members Ploughman's lunch included
For details contact S. Chamberlin, 61 Wordsworth Road, High Wycombe,
Bucks HP11 2UR.Tel. 01494 522 082. E-mail: Sylvia
Chamberlin
Tuesday 11 March 2003 at 7 pm at Roots & Shoots,
Walnut Tree Walk, Kennington Road, Lambeth SE11. Norman Carreck,
Bee Researcher at Rothamsted Research, will speak on "Current
Bee Research at Rothamsted". This date is during National Science
Week, in which David Perkins, Outreach Worker at the Wildlife Garden,
is taking a broader part, so this talk on scientific research on
bees forms a fitting contribution, and will be extremely interesting
to all bee-keepers. All LBKA members and members of neighbouring
BKAs are most welcome.
Refreshments will be served. Julian Lush JulianLush@amserve.com
22nd March 2003 - Cambridgeshire Beekeepers' Association One
Day Meeting. Speakers: Professor Martin Wolfe "Some concerns
about the use of GM"; Dr. Mark Whittaker "Biological control
and natural pollination in the UK horticulture industry''; John
Potter ''Honeybees under glass"; John Wilkins "Sniffer
bees - What are they? Exploring the potential of insect olfaction".
Ticket price of £11 includes lunch and lunch-time drinks.
Full programme (with map) and tickets available early in 2003 from
Dr. D. J. Abson, 6 Ascham Lane, Whittlesford, Cambridge, CB2 4NT
(01223 834620) SAE appreciated. E-Mail David
J. Abson
March 28 - April 2nd 2003 - Bee Products
and Apitherapy Congress and Course
Preliminary Program of the Second German Bee Products and Apitherapy
Congress and Course with International Participation, Holiday Inn
Hotel, Passau, Germany. http://www.apitherapy.com
or http://www.apitherapie.de
March 29, 2003 (Saturday) - The Northern Illinois
Beekeepers Association is proud to announce the 2003 Midwest Beekeeping
Symposium! 8:30 am 3:30 pm McHenry County College, Crystal
Lake, Illinois. The Northern Illinois Beekeepers Association and
McHenry County College present the 2003 Midwest Beekeeping Symposium.
The 2003 Symposium will combine both general sessions and numerous
small group sessions. The diverse and jam-packed agenda will range
from beginner topics to advanced such as, integrated pest management
strategies, mead making, research updates, honey competition strategies
and many more. Our 2003 featured speaker will be Dr. Dewey Caron,
Professor of Entomology, University of Delaware. His topic for the
keynote address will be Integrated Pest Management - The Best
Strategy for Mite and Pest Control Within the Hive. Dr. Caron,
author of Honey Bee Biology and Beekeeping, Africanized Honey Bees
in the Americas, and co-author of Observation Hives, is one of the
countrys most popular speakers on Beekeeping. His research
interests are insect pollination, pest/predators of honeybees and
issues in conservation of Bees and natural resources. To receive
a brochure with more information, including registration information,
e-mail your name, address and phone number to mwalsh@mchenry.edu
or call 815.455.8697. Additionally, Symposium information can be
found on the Illinois State Beekeepers Association website at www.isba.ws
The Symposium registration fee of $30.00 covers all presentations
and a Honey themed lunch. Ken Haller President, Northern Illinois
Beekeepers Association, Northern Region Director, Illinois State
Beekeepers Association.
Friday 4th - Saturday 5th April 2003 - ULSTER BEEKEEPERS'
ASSOCIATION. 59TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE,
GREENMOUNT COLLEGE, ANTRIM.
Friday, 4th April:
7.30 PM Opening ceremony
7.45 PM "Beekeepers' back, Margaret Thomas (guest lecturer).
8.30 PM "An evening with Drew Coid"
Saturday, 5th April:
9.00 AM Registration, coffee etc.
9.30 AM Welcome from Ethel Irvine, president UBKA.
Opening announcements.
9.45 AM "Varroa, its detection and spread in Ireland"
Paul Moore (DARD)
10.15 AM "Living with Varroa" Margaret Thomas.
11.30 AM "Apimondia 2005" Philip McCabe, (President, FIBKA)
12.00 "New Products" Paul Smith (Thornes)
12.15.PM "Update on New Disease Control Methods" Jeremy
Owen (Vita Europe)
12.30 PM LUNCH.
2.00 PM "Making a Varroa floor"
Tom Canning.
2.30 PM "Spring Management" Margaret Thomas.
3.15 PM Presentation of Certificates and Awards.
3.45 PM COFFEE BREAK.
4.15 PM AGM, UBKA.
Exhibitors: E.H. Thorne (Beehives), Northern
Bee Books, An Beachaire, DARD, Vita Europe Ltd., FIBKA Examination
Board.
Admission, including coffee/tea for entire
Conference £15 per person, £25 per family. Friday only,
£10 per person, £15 per family.
For On-site accommodation contact Jim Fletcher,
028 9187 2163. For other accommodation contact Walter McNeill 028
9446 4648.
12th April 2003
(Saturday) - The Yorkshire Beekeepers Association Conference.
"Something Old and Something New in the Practice of Beekeeping",
In conjunction with Bishop Burton College, Beverley East Riding
of Yorkshire. Guest Lecturers Glyn Davis - Chairman - British Beekeepers'
Association Bob Ogden - Devon Beekeepers' Association Ian Molyneux
- Regional Bees Inspector - Northern Region. Conference organisers
are Dudley Gue and Ivor Flatman.
http://www.bbka.org.uk/bbkafiles/yorkshire-bka-12april2003.pdf
[42KB PDF]
12th April 2003 (Saturday) - The West Sussex
beekeepers Association 'Practical Beekeeping' Convention at
Brinsbury College (on A29 between Pulborough and Billingshurst)
from 9.30am Speakers include: John Furzey (over 50 years of Commercial
Beekeeping) Norman Hughes (former BBKA Chairman) Richard Ball (Southwestern
Regional Bee Inspector who discovered resistant mites) Trade stands.
Lunch available in the College Restaurant. A superb day of Beekeeping.
Tickest £6 in advance or £8 on the day from Andrew Shelley,
Oakfield, Cox Green, Rudgewick, Horsham RH12 3DD (sae appreciated)
Further details, if required, on 01903 815655 or email john_bateman_hunt@hotmail.com
Email
John Bateman
26th April2003 (Saturday) The
BBKA Spring Convention. Trade Exhibitors and Educational
stands galore (about 50 - 60 in three large halls). Lectures and
Demonstrations in abundance. Download the full programme in PDF
format (1.1MB) from: http://www.beedata.com/files/bbka-spring-conv-programme2003.pdf
3rd May(Saturday)
- The Meon Valley Beekeepers Association. 24th Annual Auction sale
of Beekeeping equipment. Stocks of bees and Beekeeping books
and Plants on Saturday, May 3rd 2003 At 1.00 pm. prompt at The Village
Hall, Greatham, Nr Liss. (Off A3). Viewing from 11.30 a.m. on the
day of the sale only. It is expected that the usual large quantity
of equipment and stocks of bees will be on sale. Items for the inclusion
in the sale are now welcome. The first 300 lots accepted. Deliveries
of lots for sale to be made to the hall on the morning of the sale
only between 8.30 a.m. and 11.30 a.m. Catalogues, printed 11th April,
will be available at the sale ground or can be ordered by sending
40p and an A4 S.A.E. Commission on sales - 10% plus 50 pence per
lot entered. Information and Catalogues from Francis Farnsworth,
2 Malcolm Road, Chandlers Ford, S053 5BG Tel/Fax 023 8027 0622.
E-mail mintybees@hotmail.com
10th May 2003 - West
Sussex Beekeepers' Association Annual Bee Market and Auction
at Brinsbury College, Pulborough. Details of items for inclusion
are welcome now. Information and entry forms from David Staples,
14, Northfield Road, Worthing, West Sussex BN13 1QW (sae please)
Tel 01903 539205. Viewing from 11am. Auction at 1pm. All bees to
have disease free inspection certificate. No used or drawn comb.
John Bateman-Hunt E-mail: john_bateman_hunt@hotmail.com
78 June 2003 - Sutton Coldfield (Warwickshire) Beekeepers
Biennial Meeting. Speakers Adam Hart, David Charles, Bob Ogden,
David Kelly and Pam Gregory. Demonstration of Dartington Long Hive.
Saturday Lecture, Demonstration and evening meal. Sunday
Demonstration and Lectures with lunch available. Information from
Ruby Smith on 0121 354 7548 or e-mail routh.family@lineone.net
24-29 August 2003 - 8th International Congress
of Apimondia. Ljubljiana, Slovenia. Slovenia is to host the
38th Apimondia beekeeping Congress. The congress will be held in
the City of Ljubljiana and the congress invites the submission of
papers. Details of subjects and more information can be found on
: www.apimondia2003.com
22-25 February 2004- Apimondia Symposium
on Tropical Beekeeping: Research and Development for Pollination
and Conservation. Heredia Costa Rica More detail is available
from: Isanchez@una.ac.cr
23-27 February 2004- 7th Asian Apicultural
Association Conference Los Banos College, Lagunas, Philippines.
More information from: cleofas.cervancia@up.edu.ph
6-10 September 2004- 8th IBRA Conference
on tropical Bees: management and diversity. Ribeiro Preto, Brazil.
THE BEE PRESS BEECRAFT
The latest issue of Bee Craft offers a wealth of information, advice
and items of interest for all beekeepers in its monthly columns.
The following is its contents list:
Editorial The Small hive beetle - Ruth Waite, PhD, and Mike Brown Getting Started - Margaret Thomas, NDB The Bee Craft Directory BBKA correspondence courses - Chris Utting The 'B' Kids Thank you, Father Christmas! - Philip North All go at the National 2002 - Don Hannon Oh no! Not bee diseases again - Mike Rowbottom Rubbish removal - Celia Davis, NDB In the Apiary - the wax worm cometh - Karl Showler Beekeeping in Ireland - Eddie O'Sullivan As Dr Drone
Letters to the Editor
Around the colony
Classified advertisements and Calendar
Bee World. (Vol 83 (4) 2002) IBRA www.ibra.org.uk
Guest Editorial. Richard Cooter. Risks to UK beekeeping from the
parasitic mite. Tropilaelaps clareae and the small hive beetle Aethina
tumida. Mike Brown, Helen Thompson and Medwin Bew. Socio economic
factors in traditional rafter beekeeping with Apis dorsata in Vietnam.
Nguyen Quang Tan and Dang Thanh Ha. Estimating benefits from beekeeping
in the montane forests of north-western Cameroon. Philip Forboseh.
PLUS: IBRA News, World News. A report on the Apimondia symposium:preventing
residues in honey. Conference calendar. Beekeeping around the world.
Traditional stone apiaries in Malta. Annual Index Bee World 2002.
ARTICLES
Some thoughts about propolis in the hive
Written by John Yates
Propolis in the hive is generally regarded
as a nuisance. Hive and frame design should be aimed at minimising
it. Unfortunately this is not so and most beekeepers have to put
up with badly designed equipment; they pay good money for rubbish
and in the past I too have been caught out. I propose this month
discussing briefly two items which every beekeeper is familiar with,
that is, the propolis between the ends of the top bars and the hive
wall and between queen excluders and the top of the top bars.
First the top bar ends. Colony manipulation can
be made a lot easier if the ends of the frames are minimised in
area. This is readily achieved by cutting off 5/16 inch from each
end and replacing the missing timber with a small screw projecting
the same distance. A 3/4 inch round or pan head does the job admirably
preferably either stainless steel or brass. This simple and inexpensive
modification is shown in all three photographs A, B and C. The minimised
area is now only the head of the screw. All our frames have this
simple modification and together with using a similar screw for
frame spacing (shown upper most in photograph C) it has very nearly
made the hive tool redundant for removing frames in the brood chamber
during a colony manipulation.
Queen excluders must be the worst example of non-compliance
with the design criterion to minimise the propolising of hive parts.
Consider first the slotted types of queen excluders, originally
made in zinc sheet with either long or short slots specifically
designed to lay across the top surface of the brood chamber top
bars. Such an arrangement invites propolisation along every top
bar in the brood chamber with the result that the queen excluder
has to be peeled off breaking every joint until it becomes free.
'Touchy' bees object to this manipulation. The real problem comes
when it has to be replaced; the top bars have to be scraped clean,
with more objections from the bees, and the queen excluder itself
has to be cleaned. Cleaning the queen excluder is not easy with
a hive tool and, if it is of the long slot variety, there is high
risk of causing damage and ruining its excluding capabilities. The
only way these slotted queen excluders can be cleaned in the apiary
is by carefully scraping them with a hive tool on the top of a flat
hive roof. There are mild steel slotted types available which are
more robust and there are some made of plastic. All fail the design
criterion for minimising propolisation and should be ignored and
abandoned. There is no way that they could be adapted to be even
partially successful. They are cheap but it is a false economy,
in my opinion, to purchase them.
The next type (wire) includes the Herzog and Waldron
variety; both are similar in construction with a robust metal wire
grid enclosed in a wooden frame. A queen excluder for a National
hive will be discussed but the principle is the same for all hives.
The wooden frame is made from timber finished to 3/8 inch thick
or, more common these days, timber finished to 9mm. The wire grid
should be flush with one side of the wooden frame with a bee space
on the other side. Sometimes there is and sometimes there isn't,
depending who made the frame. Don't get caught when you buy a new
one.
The wooden framing of queen excluders vary in width, again depending
on who made them, and one that was measured from a stack of 25 in
my apiary shed had 2 sides 1¼ inches wide and the other 2
sides 11/8 inches wide with a rabbet on one side to take the wire
grid. The rabbet was made too deep leaving a gap of approximately
c inch at each side which gets filled with propolis (shown in photograph
A). The frame is jointed at the corners but it is unglued and stapled
together cheapjack fashion; eventually the staples rust and one
such example is shown clearly in photographs A and not so clearly
in photograph B.
The wooden frame should be of the same profile as
the cross section of the hive it is to fit; in the case of a National,
2 sides should be ½ inch wide and the other 2 sides ¾
inch wide. Study of the photographs A and B will make it abundantly
clear that the woodwork of the queen excluder will be in contact
with the ends of the upper surfaces of all the top bars. Also, the
top bar directly adjacent to the hive wall (photograph A) is in
contact with the queen excluder frame throughout its whole length.
These two design faults create a most unsatisfactory situation and
again make colony manipulation more difficult.
While the arrangement is much better than the slotted
types it still fails the propolis design criterion. Prising the
wooden frame from the top bars at every manipulation soon weakens
the joints and most of mine have been remade and glued.
So what is the solution? In my opinion it would
not be possible to make a wire type excluder with a wooden frame
with sides of ½ inch and ¾ inch width, it would be
insufficiently robust always assuming that the grid is large enough
to fill a frame with larger inside dimensions.
I believe that the frame should be made of mild
steel to the correct dimensions of the hive it is to fit with the
grid welded into it and the whole zinc plated after fabrication.
Different hives have different wall thickness and it would be necessary
to specify the hive it is to be used on; this should not present
a problem and a common specification could be written which would
embrace all types of hive.
Photograph B shows the end of a National brood chamber
containing 11 frames and a dummy board. The dummy board should also
have a screw at each end; the one shown hasn't and its end is clagged
up with Propolis.
The above are a few initial thoughts. For
a much more detailed and in depth discussion on the subject
of equipment design please see my monograph entitled "Beekeeping
Equipment (caveat emptor)" recently published by, and
available from, Northern Bee Books. Buy online from the URL:
http://www.beedata.com/nbb/yates.htm
(John Yates is the author of a newly published
monograph on beekeeping equipment. This timely and welcome
addition to our bookshelves will be reviewed in full in the
February issue. Ed).
Therry ApicultureNorthern France Written byRobin & Jenny Spon-Smith
rss@spon-smith.com
On our regular trips to northern France we have paid
several visits to Therry Apiculture, at Bouin Plumoison, on the D349
road about 56 miles south-east of Boulogne. This consists of a beekeeping
museum and shop. The museum contains an interesting collection of
old hives and other pieces of antique beekeeping equipment. The shop
has a limited amount of equipment for sale - such as smokers and gloves
- and a wide range of honey and bee products, such as sweets, biscuits,
honey vinegar, mead and so on.
There is also a small auditorium in which there
is a video concerning honey bees and beekeeping permanently showing.
(Commentary only in French, unfortunately!) There is also an indoor
hive, whose exit to the open air is via a glass sided passage.
One of the most impressive features is a cellar
containing a large quantity of barrels of mead and mead making equipment.
Mr. Therry describes mead as "La boisson des Gaulois"
- the drink of the Gauls.
Behind the premises is a bee garden with several
hives, but evidently most of his colonies must be kept elsewhere.
When we visited Bouin Plumoison last September we
found a party of French schoolchildren there, being shown how honey
was extracted. Surprisingly, some of them had apparently never tasted
honey, and a few turned up there noses in disgust when offered pieces
of comb - despite being assured by Robin that it was 'delicieux'!
When the children were taken into the garden there was no suggestion
of veils being provided, and Mr. Therry even encouraged them to
touch bees. In this country the fear of a claim for damages if one
of the children was stung would probably discourage anybody from
doing that.
Also present was a young lady reporter from a local
radio station. Realising that Robin was a beekeeper from England,
she recorded an interview with him. We didn't discover whether it
was ever broadcast!
Therry Apiculture is well worth a visit by any beekeeper
who finds himself in the Pas de Calais. It is advertised as open
Mondays to Fridays from 2 p.m. until 7 p.m., on Saturdays 'toute
la journée' (all day - whatever that may mean), and on Sundays
from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. except in January. It advertises guided visits
for parties of more than 20. The address is 923 rue Nationale, but
it is easily found as Bouin Plumoison is only a small village.
The day that changed my life
Written by Peter Springall ps@zbee.com
Have you ever looked back on what seemed to be quite
a small incident at the time to realise that the small incident has
become a turning point in your life? Such an occasion happened to
me many years ago.
I had been keeping bees for about fifteen years
and had recently introduced my friend George to the joys of beekeeping.
In his first flush of enthusiasm, and being a person never to do
anything by halves, he was going all over the place buying hives
from whatever source he could find. One of the vendors turned out
to be the president of the local Branch of Beekeepers, which was
a big eye opener for me, as I hadn't realised there was such a thing
as 'A Local Branch'.
I mentioned having kept bees for fifteen years.
Fifteen years of joy and agony.
Joy at the wonders of this remarkable hobby and agony from the inevitable
stings that caused me to break out in a cold sweat at the mere thought
of opening up a hive. However the joy always won and I worried about
the agony afterwards.
Needless to say I hurried along to the next meeting
of this newly discovered branch and met this wonderful band of experts,
one of whom turned out to be a gentleman by the name of Manny Hedges.
Now in those days sugar was rationed and some how or other my name
found it's way onto a list. I would get home from work in the evening
and my mother would announce, "Oh, I've got three for you this
evening" or something similar. She was of course referring
to swarms. Somehow or other the local Police had got my name off
the list.
The conversation with Manny Hedges inevitably turned
to swarms and the funny places one would find them. Having described
one of these situations I asked, "What would you do if you
were called to such a situation Mr Hedges?" "Oh that's
easy, what yer do is rolls up yer sleeves, put's yer 'ands in and
claims 'em". My eyes popped out. "Oh".
Well, a week went by and such a difficult situation
did arise. There was the swarm on a rickety old fence with an overhanging
privet hedge and three-inch holes spaced along the fence at one-foot
intervals as part of the decoration.
The swarm had taken possession of one of the holes. Shaking the
fence with the risk of the swarm dropping down each side at best
and the fence collapsing at worst or smoking them up into the hedge
didn't seem to be an option. 'Putting my hands in and claiming them'
seemed to be the solution.
The onlookers were congregated at a safe distance
across the road. Good I thought at least they won't see my sweat
and I can conceal any signs of being stung, so in I went. One or
two gentle puffs of smoke then opening both hands I judged where
the hole was and gently pressed my fingers into the swarm. Lots
of prickles as the bees ran all over my hands, but this is wonderful!
No stings - yet. Gently closing my hands together until my fingertips
were touching, then one firm shake and lo and behold they were running
into the box I had prepared for them.
Three weeks passed and it was time for the next
beekeepers meeting. I proudly announced to Mr Hedges "it worked
Mr Hedges". He looked up at me "what was that son? He
asked. "Well putting your hands in and claiming them".
Horror spread over his face "my god you didn't" he said
"I was joshing you"!
Those few moments were to change my life of beekeeping.
Never again have I broken out in a cold sweat. No longer fearing
bees I seldom get stung and if I do it hurts the bee more than it
does me such is the immunity I have developed from all those stings
in those far off days.
George carried on beekeeping with about a dozen
hives on a site he used to go to for the weekends. When he decided
to leave for Australia he left his hives in my friend Arthur's capable
hands. One day Arthur told me that George used to spend most of
his time on Sundays picking out the maggots that his wife had spotted
in the cells. Such is beekeeping!
Matt Allens View
EMERSON, AN IDIOT
A debate on the radio last week centred on the issue
of whether genes responsible for antisocial behaviour can be identified,
and if they can be identified, does that mean the person with those
genes can be held responsible, for (let us take a random example)
say, burgling an office and comprehensively smashing it up after
taking all the computer equipment? (Not such a random example, actually,
because I had a call from the police just half an hour ago, who
found my phone number in the wreckage of my company's head office?
Anyway, that's one big headache for us to deal with.) Maybe the
perpetrators are victims of their genes, and it's not their fault.
In my youth I had a Victorian book on phrenology, which claimed
that people's characters can be deduced from the shape of their
heads, such as the dissipated type, the criminal type, the noble
type, the heroic type, blah blah blah. The finest woodcut of all,
and the most fearsome, was that of 'Emerson, An Idiot' whose visage
comprised deepset eyes below eyebrows like the Himalayas, almost
no cranium and a jaw like Desperate Dan's. Emerson's terrifying
scowl has stuck in my memory all these years, and now I picture
him ransacking our office.
Hang on, I'm getting carried away here. I didn't
mean to write about phrenology, but phenology this month. In my
last ramblings ('le mot juste,' grumble our continental readers)
I was talking about my fields of wild flowers, and how the plants
which germinated in October were poking up a few millimetres from
the soil. It's been wet for sure, but not yet cold, and still these
plants are putting on growth - in December! It seems to me the winters
have been getting milder, in fact downright cissie recently, but
my memory is hopeless. So that's where I have to listen to real
experts.
At the weekend it was a pleasure to attend a lecture
by Sir Ghillean Prance (who is as far removed from Emerson as you
could imagine). Sir Ghillean was the Director of Kew Gardens before
taking up his present position as Scientific Director at the Eden
Project. He talked about a whole range of environmental issues,
including climate change, saying that global warming is indisputable.
How's this for a statistic? The hottest eight years ever recorded
in the UK all occurred in the past decade! (So my little plants
stand a fighting chance of getting through winter.) And he went
on to discuss phenology, which is the study of the flowering times
of plants. This is a field that I believe is largely dominated by
passionate amateurs who report from all over the UK. The astonishing
figure is that over a few decades, plants in the UK are flowering
on average seven days earlier. Let me stress that he is talking
about average - many plants are flowering up to 30 days earlier.
This doesn't just mean that the weather is a little more pleasant
for us, but there are global implications. For instance, the Maldives
- islands which reach only a few feet above the Indian Ocean - may
need to be renamed Atlantis as they disappear below the Indian Ocean.
Nevertheless, the lecture, which was very wide-ranging,
finished with an attempt to be optimistic. I can pluck all sorts
of examples and quotes from my notes, but I understand the text
(and hopefully illustrations) will be available on-line. I shall
attempt to find the web-site in case anyone is interested.
LETTERS Dear Editor,
Reply to John Yates on Bad tempered bees in the United Kingdom
In the article Bad tempered bees in
the United Kingdom Mr. Yates states Apis mellifera
intermissa or the Tellian bee from NW Africa is considered to
be a major race from which the bees in western Europe developed
such as the Iberian bee, the French blacks, the old English bee,
etc. All these bees have the aggressive instinct of the Tellian
bee and these aggressive genes are to be found throughout the UK.
This is a notion that is challenged by recent research.
At the University of Copenhagen Dr. Bo Vest Pedersen studied the
mitochondrial DNA of numerous samples of honeybee and found that
there are three major groupings of Apis mellifera. In the
distant past Apis mellifera separated from Apis cerana and
became established as a distinct species. It is inferred from the
DNA studies that some of these bees later migrated sometime between
a half and one million years ago to evolve into the Apis mellifera
mellifera group. At a later stage further divisions produced
the other two groups, one migration evolving into the subspecies
of south and east Europe, i.e. the Italian, Carniolan, Greek, Caucasian
bees etc, with the other group forming the subspecies of Africa
including the Tellian bee.
Ruttner (1988a) describes how, during the last Ice
Age A. m. mellifera was confined to the valleys of southern
France, until the ice began to melt about ten thousand years ago
when the bees were able to extend northwards (in association with
flora that provided food and deciduous trees that provided nesting
sites) to colonise most of Europe north of the Pyrenees and the
Alps including Britain and Ireland, southern Norway and across Russia
as far as the Urals.
Dr. Pedersen also states that it has been shown
that the Iberian subspecies, A. m. iberica is the result
of an introgressive hybridisation of local European bees by an African
subspecies.
Mr. Yates asks why the change to aggressive bees
in this country has taken place over the past 70 years. From the
above mentioned studies we can assume that the aggressive
genes to which Mr. Yates refers are not inherited from the
Tellian bee. The primary cause of aggressive behaviour in our honeybees
is the cross breeding of different subspecies resulting from the
continued importation during those 70 years of foreign bees into
this country. Professor Friedrich Ruttner wrote Unfortunately,
most racial crosses incline towards increased stinginess, even when
outstandingly gentle races are used for crossing. If anyone brings
bees of a foreign race to his apiary he will hybridise the entire
neighbourhood.
The writer of these notes has kept bees for sixty
of the seventy years mentioned by Mr. Yates. The majority of the
aggressive bees I have encountered during that time have been inter-racial
hybrids. Black bees of mixed ancestry give a bad reputation to the
native bee that is unwarranted, just as yellow bees of mixed ancestry
give the Italian bee a bad reputation. I now have productive and
gentle black native bees that are handled without gloves or the
use of smoke. This has been achieved by choosing a very good local
strain and ruthlessly culling any queens that mate with imported
or hybrid drones.
Unfortunately, too many beekeepers in this country,
being unaware of the virtues or existence of the native bee, look
for the quick and easy fix by buying foreign queens,
thereby perpetuating the problem of aggressive behaviour.
Apart from the efforts of individual members, there
are now 22 groups spread throughout the country working in BIBBA
to produce good tempered, productive native bees only to be frustrated
at times when other beekeepers bring imported or hybrid drones within
flying distance of their apiaries.
Surely the time has come for beekeepers in this
country to take the long term view and work together and with nature
to conserve and improve the best of the native bees still surviving.
References:
Pedersen, B. V. 1996. On the phylogenetic
position of the Danish strain of the black honeybee (the Laeso bee),
Apis mellifera mellifera L., inferred from mitochondrial DNA sequences.
Entomologica Scandinavica 27; 241 250.
Ruttner F. 1988 (English translation) Breeding Techniques
and Selection for Breeding of the Honeybee. BIBBA.
Ruttner F. 1988a. Biogeography and Taxonomy of Honeybees.
Springer-Verlag. John E Dews
8th January 2003
Reply to John Dews
The purpose of my article, which appears to have been overlooked
by Mr Dews, was to enquire whether there was a better way to determine
the aggressive character of a stock of bees for examination purposes;
ie. better than the one that I postulated whereby the greater the
distance the followers follow, the greater the aggressiveness.
It was Bro. Adam, the greatest bee breeder the world has known,
who classed the Tellian bee (Intermissa) as a major race from which
all those NW European bees evolved. The other major race in N.Africa,
Fasciata, is the forerunner of the Italian and other docile bees
of SE Europe. Bro. Adam was the only person with any real experience
of the English brown or black bee, who has committed his findings
to paper. He is on record as saying that it had some good qualities
but it also had some bad ones; bad temper was its major failing
together with its susceptibility to disease.
I don't think that it is proven that the primary cause of bad temper
is due to introgressive hybridisation. Bad temper is exhibited,
to a greater or lesser degree, by all the NW European bees. Conversely
to what Mr. Dews states, it is also possible to get very docile
bees from a cross between two very aggressive strains; this was
also shown by Bro. Adam.
I do agree with him partially on one point that it is very easy
to breed a good tempered bee simply by culling the bad ones, not
from the native bee per se but from the 'riff raff' which are now
native. Few beekeepers manage to do this and it is to be noted that
it is unnecessary to seek out a particular strain.
BIBBA's aims to produce good tempered bees on a national scale is
admirable but, unfortunately it is, in my opinion, a pipe dream
without Governmental assistance with funding and compulsory registration
of all beekeepers; something which is unlikely to happen. J.D
Dear Editor,
Thanks for an informative and varied issue. Although
you seem to qualify your poll questions below:
"If GMO research was stopped completely,
do you think:
A. We would be abandoning a young science that if perfected may
bring enormous benefits to mankind and the planet OR
B. We would be saving mankind and the planet from potential or actual
disaster
C. You don't know enough about the subject.
It is extremely difficult to formulate a question
without drawing some criticism about its bias or accusations of
'leading'. I've thought a lot about this and believe that the question
above is as fair as possible. But to make this small survey of any
use, we do need your participation, so do have ago from the links
below. Vote once only please. The GMO Poll Expires: Dec 23, 2002
(Tue)."
I would like to complain at being forced to vote
"A" to participate. My GM knowledge is fairly reasonable,
so I can't vote "C". "B" is an extreme viewpoint
when applied to stopping research completely, but if applied to
halting farm scale field trials on modified crops it would be quite
reasonable, and my vote at present. I feel that the poll may result
in some people not voting, or like myself, being forced to cast
what appears to be a supporting vote for the status quo on GM trials.
"B" is an emotively written, untenable
position, is that your intention?
I feel that you have confused 'research' with 'field
trials'. Only idiots would stop research...or trial theories that
were not fully researched. Wouldn't they? The problem with GM (and
in fact with most industrialisation and new technology) is not the
product...it is the motivation. If this technology is going to feed
the masses of the world I'd feel a lot more comfortable if there
was more evidence of helping hands from the West, and a little less
of the clenched fist! The belief that GM is simply a means to concentrate
power in the hands of wealthy seed barons for personal (read stockholders/read
YOUR INSURANCE/PENSION) gain cannot be ignored. This is a difficult
subject, with many levels. I think your poll is a brave and excellent
idea...but feel it may mislead. My reasoned vote certainly does
not reflect my opinion...which is nothing new! John Sewell
Dear David,
Greetings from a cold Greece - a icy wind is coming from the snow-covered
mountain tops and we are suffering night-time temperatures of just
6C. Brrr.
There are a couple of things in the latest issue
of Apis UK I would like to comment on.
Firstly, the GM technology. I welcome the idea of
the reader survey and although you gave a lot of thought to the
questions, I am not sure that they were the right ones. I say this
because the whole issue of technology is ultimately about responsibility
and if we could rely on scientists and 'big business' to take these
responsibilities seriously - a difficult conflict when multi-dollar
companies are involved and their business essentially is about making
money and certainly not philanthropy, then there might be more confidence
in the industry. I think many people would agree that there is a
place for the technology - particularly in a 'closed' environment,
where the likelihood of 'escape' and 'contamination' are not likely
to be a problem. That we cannot trust some scientists/companies
is clearly evident by the cloning programme which is currently underway,
and I am sure that there are enough egoists, with money, who would
like to have clones of themselves, a dangerous and unethical scenario.
What I am really saying is that whilst the science can be good,
it is the use to which it put that is the determining factor about
its usefulness or dangerousness to mankind, cf the nuclear industry.
GM technology covers so many things, many none of us are aware of
- perhaps it would have been better in a beekeeping magazine to
ask whether or not the readers thought that the GM planting of crops
would, or not, have an adverse affect on beekeeping. I do not like
the idea of the running tally of votes so that everyone can see
which way the voting is going - the results could easily be manipulated
one way or another. A closed ballot boz would have been much better.
Secondly, referring to 'holy bees'. There still
exists amongst certain devout Greek Orthodox people in this area
the belief that if you put an icon in a beehive, then the bees will
never cover the Madonna's (or any saint's) face with wax. In the
manner of the tabloids (the sort that travel many miles to take
a photograph of a black patch on a Friesian cow which resembles
some personality's face) this was put to the test and televised.
I am told the icon was clear of any wax on the face. Mmm. I think
this calls for some research. Best wishes and keep up the good work.
JohnPhipps
Dear David,
I was interested in the article by John Yates in the December issue
of Apis UK, and agree fully with his view of most modern bees. I've
always understood that aggression or defensiveness was a different
characteristic to following. Aggression could be measured by the
means of a cloth-covered ball dangled over the open hive and then
counting the number of stings in a given time.
On the question of the cost of Queens, the average house price in
many parts of the country for a semi-detached house is probably
closer to £50,000 and that would make the cost of a queen
to be about £5. I would be interested to know where one could
buy a quality Queen for £5, or even for £10. Regards,
John Burgess, Editor Gwenynwyr Cymru/The Welsh Beekeeper.
Reply to John Burgess
Yes, John Burgess is right, a small leather covered ball dangling
in front of a colony was (is?) used for measuring aggressiveness
in order to determine which colonies may be best used to collect
bee venom. However, the purpose of my measurement is to define a
simple way to determine which colonies should be used for the BBKA
Husbandry Examination. I have observed that following may be equated
with aggressiveness. It is to be noted that the most aggressive
bee in the world, the Africanised Honey Bee (AHB), follows regularly
to 1 km from its hive.
The cost of a semi in London is of the order that
I stated; elsewhere may be different. Queens have been advertised
in Devon for around the £10 mark but what are advertised as
quality queens is another matter. Breeding your own from the local
'riff raff' is just as good. J.D
Dear Editor,
Having just received the reminder I have looked at the so-called
readers' survey and reluctantly filled it in. This does us all a
disservice as the question is loaded and the results will be meaningless.
As a scientist, but also a keen environmentalist, I try to keep
an open mind and ignore the hype around this topic. There are dangers
and I believe that more care is needed before any crops are introduced,
especially into Europe, but the public have become suspicious of
anything called 'genetic modification' and that is unfortunate and
unnecessary. Dairy starters for example have been in common use
for may years and are both valuable and harmless. Pamela
A Hunter. Freelance Medical Writer and Microbiological Consultant
Dear Editor,
MELLIFERA is the first scientific beekeeping journal in Turkey.
Languages (Turkish and English). It is that the journal has been
found eligible for screening by the ULAKBIM National Indices and
"APICULTURAL ABSTRACTS" of Ulrich's International Periodicals,
BIOSIS and EBSCO. Correspondence address, Subscription form, Instruction
to authors and other detailed information can you find at, www.tkv-dft.org/publications/index.htm
Or write to mellifera@ktg.com.tr With my best regards, Editor of
Mellifera Assoc. Prof. Kadriye Sorkun
HISTORICAL NOTE WONDERFUL WAX
In a recent issue I dealt with the virtues and properties of Mead.
Now it is the turn of wax. The initial description is perfectly
said.
(From: England's Interest, 4th edition. Sir John More 1707).
"Wax hath no fixed elementary quality, but is a mean between
hot and cold, and between dry and moist. It mollifies the sinews;
it ripeneth and resolveth ulcers; the quantity of a pea of wax being
swallowed down by nurses, disolveth the milk curdled in their breasts;
and ten round pieces of wax, of the bigness of the grains of millet
or hempseed, will not suffer the milk to curdle in the stomach.
Moreover it maketh the most excellent light for clearness, and sweetness,
and neatness, to be preferred before all others, and is such as
is used in the palaces of kings and princes."
"Natural wax is altered by distillation into an oyl of marvellous
vertue: it is rather a celestial or divine medicine, than humane;
because in wounds it worketh miracles, and is therefore opposed
by the surgeons, tho they use it themselves; for it healeth a wound,
be it never so wide and big, being before stitch'd up, in 10 or
12 days at the most; but it healeth those that are small in 3 or
4 days only by anointing the wound therewith, and applying a cloth
wet in the same. It stayeth the shedding of the hair on the head
or face, by anointing therewith.
For inward diseases this oyl worketh miracles. If you give 1 dram
at a time in white wine, it will provoke urine, help stitches and
pains in the loins, the cold gout and all other grief's coming of
cold". (All this is most appropriate for the winter months, so next
month 'how to make this oyl'. You will need, wax, plenty of sweet
wine, some red brick powder, sand and some finely sifted ashes.
Ed).
Editor: David CrampSubmissions
contact the Editor Web Editor: Steven Turner
E-mail addresses are not hyper linked to prevent harvesting for
spamming purposes. We recommend you cut & paste to your e-mail
client if required.